Drip Tape vs Drip Line
Drip tape is thin-walled and usually used for one season or a few. Drip line has a thick wall and is built to stay in the field for many years.
Why it matters
The choice drives yearly cost, labor and waste. Tape is cheaper to buy but needs yearly handling and disposal, while line costs more at first and lasts longer when it is protected and cleaned.
Step by step
- List your crop type, row length, planting cycle and whether you will lift and replace tubing each season.
- Compare wall thickness, emitter spacing and flow rates at your operating pressure for each product class.
- Estimate yearly handling labor, including laying, retrieving, repairs and disposal of used material.
- Calculate cost per 1,000 feet per season for each, dividing purchase cost by expected seasons of use.
- Find the break-even number of seasons where line becomes cheaper than tape, and compare it with your plan.
What good looks like
A good choice matches the product to your cropping pattern. Short season annual crops often suit tape, while perennials and long rotations favor line that stays in place.
Worked example
Illustrative per 1,000 feet. Tape costs 40 plus 10 handling and disposal, so 50 per season. Line costs 160, used 8 seasons, or 20 per year, plus 12 upkeep. Break-even solves 50n equals 160 plus 12n, so n is 4.2. After about 5 seasons line is cheaper.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Comparing purchase price without counting retrieval and disposal labor.
- Burying thin tape where rodent damage is likely.
- Choosing line for crops that will be removed after one season.
- Forgetting that line still needs flushing and clog prevention.
Safety, legal and compliance notes
Used plastic tubing may carry disposal or recycling rules. Ask your local solid waste office about options, and never burn used drip material unless local rules clearly allow it.
What to record
Keep a dated equipment file: purchase date and cost, model and serial numbers, nozzle and sprinkler package charts, pump curves, inspection and repair history, parts replaced, flow and pressure readings and energy use. Good records help you plan replacements, prove performance and support warranty or insurance claims.
When to ask for help
Electrical, well, backflow and chemigation rules vary by state and utility. Talk with the equipment manufacturer or dealer, your extension irrigation specialist, your NRCS or conservation district office, a licensed electrician and your electric utility before you install, modify or repair major equipment. The state directory lists agencies and resources in every state.
Frequently asked questions
Does tape clog more than line?
Both clog if filtration is poor. Tape has thinner walls and smaller passages, so it is less forgiving of dirty water.
Can drip line stay in the field all winter?
Often yes if drained and protected, but check your climate and the manufacturer's guidance for freezing, rodents and sunlight exposure.
Which suits vegetables?
Tape often fits annual vegetables with yearly rotation. Perennial crops such as berries and orchards usually favor durable line.
Related guides
- Drip Irrigation System Basics
- Drip Zone and Flow Design Worksheet
- Micro-Sprinklers and Emitters Compared
- Drip System Flushing Routine
- How Irrigation Pumps Work
- Pump Selection Basics
More from the network
Farm news, humor and ranch life at farm.FM.