Irrigation System Cost Comparison Worksheet
This worksheet puts every option on the same footing: annual cost per acre. Fill one column per system and the total shows what each really costs you each year.
Why it matters
Purchase price hides the real cost. A cheaper system can cost more per acre once energy, repairs and labor are counted, and a costly one may pay back through lower pumping. One comparable number prevents expensive surprises.
Step by step
- Make one column per system with rows for installed cost, expected life in years, yearly repairs, yearly energy and yearly labor.
- Divide installed cost by expected life to get the annual capital cost for each system.
- Estimate energy as kWh used per season times your local rate, using your own pumping hours and pressure.
- Add all annual rows for each system, then divide the total by irrigated acres to get cost per acre.
- Add a row for expected yield or quality gains, and compare the extra cost per acre against that gain.
What good looks like
A good worksheet has every cell filled with a written source or assumption, uses the same acres and years for each option, and ends with a clear annual cost per acre you can defend.
Worked example
Illustrative, 100 acres. System A: 90,000 over 20 years is 4,500, plus repairs 1,500, energy 6,000, labor 1,000, total 13,000, or 130 per acre. System B: 150,000 over 15 years is 10,000, plus 2,000, 3,500 and 500, total 16,000, or 160 per acre. B must return 30 more per acre.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Using different life spans without dividing capital cost by each life.
- Leaving out labor because it is your own time.
- Guessing energy use instead of working from pumping hours and pressure.
- Ignoring replacement parts such as tires, filters and tubing in repairs.
Safety, legal and compliance notes
Financing, tax treatment and cost-share programs depend on your situation. Talk with your lender, tax professional or local conservation agency office before relying on any figure in the worksheet.
What to record
Keep a dated equipment file: purchase date and cost, model and serial numbers, nozzle and sprinkler package charts, pump curves, inspection and repair history, parts replaced, flow and pressure readings and energy use. Good records help you plan replacements, prove performance and support warranty or insurance claims.
When to ask for help
Electrical, well, backflow and chemigation rules vary by state and utility. Talk with the equipment manufacturer or dealer, your extension irrigation specialist, your NRCS or conservation district office, a licensed electrician and your electric utility before you install, modify or repair major equipment. The state directory lists agencies and resources in every state.
Frequently asked questions
How do I estimate energy cost?
Multiply pumping hours by motor kilowatts, then by your rate. A pump professional or utility representative can help check the kilowatt figure.
Which life span should I use?
Use a realistic working life from growers with similar equipment, not the maximum. Shorter assumptions for wearing parts such as tubing keep the comparison honest.
Should I include yield gains?
Yes, but as a separate row with a stated source. Keep costs and benefits apart so you can see both clearly.
Related guides
- Choosing an Irrigation System
- Irrigation Terms Explained
- Matching Equipment to Crop and Soil
- Irrigation Equipment Buying Checklist
- How a Center Pivot Works
- Pivot Sprinkler Package Basics
More from the network
Farm news, humor and ranch life at farm.FM.